Brand: Eagle Rare
Proof: 90
Age: 10 years
Distillery: Buffalo Trace
Mash Bill: Less than 10% rye
Eagle Rare 10-Year-Old is a well-regarded bourbon from the renowned Buffalo Trace distillery. Known for its complexity and balance, this bourbon is crafted with a mash bill that includes less than 10% rye, lending it a unique character.
Appearance and Aroma
One of the standout features of Eagle Rare is its enticing nose. As soon as you pour a glass, you’re greeted with a rich bouquet of honey, graham cracker, and caramel. There’s a subtle hint of apple, reminiscent of apple suckers, adding a fruity twist to the classic bourbon aromas. Notably, the presence of smoke upon opening was significant. This “smoke” is the little bit of air inside the bottle that has chemicals, like ethanol. When it mixes with fresh air, it makes a visible mist. An additional point was awarded to the nose due to the satisfying pop of the cork and the accompanying smoke, elevating the nose rating from 3 to 4.
Nose Rating: 4/5
Palate
On the palate, Eagle Rare delivers a classic bourbon profile with dominant notes of vanilla, oak, and caramel. The oak presence is significant, complemented by hints of baked apple and brown sugar, almost akin to an apple pie. Despite its rich flavors, it lacks the intense warmth known as the “Kentucky hug” that many high-proof bourbon enthusiasts crave. This 90-proof bourbon is smooth and well-balanced, though it might not satisfy those looking for a stronger kick.
Palate Rating: 2.5/5
Finish
The finish of Eagle Rare is notably oily but doesn’t linger long. It leaves a pleasant aftertaste of apple and baking spice, rounding out the tasting experience. While solid, the finish might feel a bit short for some, but it maintains the bourbon’s overall balance and smoothness.
Finish Rating: 2/5
Overall Impression
Eagle Rare 10-Year-Old is a solid bourbon, particularly valued for its approachable price point. At an MSRP of $40 and a secondary market price ranging up to $120, it offers good value, especially if found under $45. While it might not be a top pick for those who prefer higher proof spirits, it’s a worthwhile addition for fans of smooth, classic bourbons with a rich, smoky nose.
Final Score: 2.67/5
Value and Availability
Given its rarity and demand, Eagle Rare can be a challenge to find at MSRP. The price you pay can significantly influence your perception of its value. For those who enjoy its flavor profile, paying up to $45 is reasonable. Pours typically cost between $5 and $10, though due to its rarity, prices can go up to $15. Anything over $20 for a pour may not be justifiable.
Is it worth the hunt?
This is subjective. If you’re a fan of higher proof bottles, this might not be your go-to. However, for those who appreciate a well-crafted, smooth bourbon with a hint of smoke, Eagle Rare 10-Year-Old is worth seeking out, especially at a reasonable price.